Tweeting @GraemeSmith49, a lesson in etiquette

by mspr1nt on November 7, 2010

in General Sweeps, South Africa

This is going to sound like a ridiculously hypocritical post and it probably is to an extent but for once I actually feel sorry for the SA skipper .

Twitter and social media in general is a public domain (unless, of course, you protect your Tweets). ORM for oneself is as important as it is for business and we have to think before we Tweet in order to prevent looking like fools when it all comes out or when somebody stumbles across something we said.

I’ve given Kevin Pietersen a fair bit of a hard time, no more than I would do to him face-to-face but we all know how that ended up, he blocked me on Twitter and deservedly so.

On Friday night a Tweet form a South African fan to Graeme Smith was Retweeted by the Saffa skip for all the world to see. Fortunately for the Tweeter most people have a life and their Friday nights are mostly spent getting drunk or doing social things of sort.

The Tweet read as follows: @GraemeSmith49 You prick. Big joke when you cock up. Very funny. You are the problem, step down and let Botha do the job.

I’ve elected to not disclose who this Tweeter is but I’m sure most of you saw it/can use your common sense to find it.

I’ve never had much love for Smithers and while I tend to fire the insults at the television screen and around my mates I’m quite selective about what I write about him and what I Tweet to him. It’s a respect thing. I’ve drawn conclusions and made assumptions about the kind of person I’d imagine Smith to be and, to be honest, I’ve decided, without ever meeting him, that I probably won’t like him.

I respect him tremendously as a player and, in my opinion, he is one of the most successful Test captains South Africa has ever had and he is the player I’ve watch grow the most since his tenure at the helm of the South African cricket team began. Add to that the fact that the is also a massively talented cricketer and there is no reason why he doesn’t deserve respect. That doesn’t mean I have to like him.

Smith has a tough job. Not only does he have to motivate, captain and inspire a team that seems to be lacking that killer instinct but he also has to captain a team that’s lathered with issues stemming from politics. It’s not a pretty landscape and it’s not a job that anyboby wants, nevermind a job that people would be good at.

Yes, South Africa tend to choke (yawn) yes, we don’t have that oomph that other international nations seem to have, yes, there are issues and yes, there is perhaps a clique but is it a job you want or even a job you’d be good at? I highly doubt it.

Smith has made his mistakes but he has more than made up for them in the past few years. Yes, we get annoyed when he laughs when we are losing under stupid circumstances but that’s just the way some people deal with it. I was about 13 when I broke my arm and I laughed about it. It wasn’t that it didn’t hurt, it was just that I didn’t know what else to do. When I was hijacked in a driveway and had somebody stick a gun in my side, I laugh when the crooks drove off because that’s the way I deal with things.

I’ve said some very nasty things about Smith’s laughing attitude in the past but I think that it’s simply the way he deals with it.

Personally I am not a fan of the whole ‘we must get behind the team and support them no matter what’ attitude.  I’m quite a opinionated and probably one of the biggest Protea bashers around but that doesn’t mean I don’t love my team and it doesn’t mean that I don’t respect them and that I don’t understand how hard they do work.

Arm chair critic syndrome can be fatal and maybe, just maybe, it is time we cut the South African skip some slack. Maybe, just maybe, he’ll “surprise” the haters and bring back a nice trophy from India in 2011….

{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }

Smithers November 8, 2010 at 12:42 pm

I think by going Public on twitter, sportsmen and women have to be prepared for the abuse from arm-chair critics and the loonies.
After the Ireland game, Bryan Habana replied to one such Springbok fan: “How about you take your negativity elsewhere.. And I’m not ur budd!!!” RT @burgertmull: @BryanHabana time to retire budd!

I’m no fan of Smith either, I think he’s a bully of a batsman bashing the ball with that bottom hand, rather than stroking it gently like Kallis or Sachin.
But he’s our captain and he is the one who has to take responsibility when we lose. And he also has to take the criticism, no matter how crude and mis-placed by those out there in Social Network Land.
He’s got a big enough chin, so I think he can take it.
Smithers´s last [type] ..MrSmithMachine- @ Greenstone waiting for Dispicable Me to start Popcorn- Coke and MnMs for breakfast

Reply

Smithers November 8, 2010 at 12:45 pm

Forgot to add:
He may not be everyone’s 1st choice captain, but his record is pretty impressive since he took over. And don’t forget, there weren’t that many people rushing to be SA Captain when he took over.
So I say well done Biff!
Smithers´s last [type] ..MrSmithMachine- @ Greenstone waiting for Dispicable Me to start Popcorn- Coke and MnMs for breakfast

Reply

mspr1nt November 9, 2010 at 11:49 am

Yeah, exactly my point. And I agree that sportsmen who go public on Twitter and everywhere else accept that they would have to deal with a load of rubbish but it’s so not needed sometimes.

I also saw that Habana Tweet and it was just so distasteful and unnecessary.

Reply

Fearlessdealer November 8, 2010 at 12:58 pm

I think whoever it is wanting Biff to stand down and let Botha take over needs to keep 2 things in mind:
1. Be patient. After the 2011 world cup Biff will be handing over the reigns to someone (not necessarily but likely to be Botha)
2. Botha didn’t exactly lead the side to crushing wins in the games he WAS in charge did he?

I have a whole lot of respect for Biff as a player and a captain. Yes, he’s not always got things right, but who does? One thing is for sure, when he’s in charge, the players know who’s in charge. And that’s not a bad thing. A young team such as this one (in my opinion anyway) needs a good, strong captain otherwise it’s very easy for things to head south, and stay there. Just look at Aussie as an example. In my view Ponting (and Clarke is even worse) is too soft with the team, and it’s shown in their results. When under pressure, they disappear. Now that’s fine when you’ve got strong, experienced players who don’t really need captaining (think Warne and McGrath here), but with a bunch of newbies, they need all the help they can get.

I’m sure Biff (and all the other sportspersons on Twitter) know that if they want to be out there they will cop some flak on occasions, and will deal with that in their own ways, but sometimes the flak they get and how it is dealt with reveals a whole lot about both sides of the discussion, and the bigger “prick” (if I may) is often the one making the initial tweet, and not the one replying.

Reply

mspr1nt November 9, 2010 at 11:51 am

“Yes, he has not always done things, right but who has?”
Spot on….also….captaining a national team, especially in a political landscape like South Africa is far harder than just being an ordinary citizen. Smith has done a great job with the team….I’ll be sad when he stands down as one-day skip next year.
If Amla is to take over as Test captain I wonder how his ‘softness’ will go down with the squad?

Reply

Simon November 8, 2010 at 2:14 pm

I’m a huge Smith fan. I am glad he is captain for a host of reasons. That being said, one of the things I like about Smith is that he is ballsy and is prepared to get rough and aggressive (on and off the field) and an attitude like that will always garner people throwing their own opnoions your way.

After Wessels, Hansie and Polly who were all decent captains in their own right, it is great that SA has a good ballsy, conforntational, loud, lead-from-the-front kind of guy. And it is thos attitude, good for cricket in my book, which will get him kak on twitter and in general.

So be it.
Simon´s last [type] ..simonwillo- Has this really been happening for 3 years http-bitly-bBa54n btw that Simon in the comments is not me

Reply

mspr1nt November 9, 2010 at 11:52 am

Yeah, I’m a fan of how he has been aggressive and some of his tactics but as person (and I must reiterate that I have never met him) I don’t think I’ll like him. Just because he probably was that ‘aggressive’ and bullish ‘jock’ in high school who bullied nerds like me :)
But that’s a personal thing and I don’t have an issue with his captaincy, etc.

Reply

knowledge_eater November 9, 2010 at 7:39 am

Oh no he won’t because they will be losing in Semi-final against India. I am getting bit worried now seeing JP getting back to form. ABD has been doing well also seeing the way Amla going in one-dayers. I think they are the biggest hurdle for India. Captaincy is very subjective thing in One-dayers if everyone do their job properly. Test is whole different level. But speaking of Smith, he is one of the ballsiest Cricket Captain around, I kind of hate saying this (since its bad for India) this team is slowly getting into the team when they played 99 world cup, except Klusner is not around, he was class act. Hard to replace player like that. Morkel comes close. If that left hander Parnell comes back from injury. Morkel and Parnell can feel gap of Klusner. Done. With team like this. Only superman performance or collective team performance like Pakistan and India (have done when they played them recently) can stop them in World Cup.

Reply

knowledge_eater November 9, 2010 at 7:44 am

Ohh btw I just found out we don’t have to find out what kind of tweets Cricketers receive every time only from Retweets, we can just click on side symbol and can find out … thats excellent way to stalk the stalker. Damn I didn’t know that.

Reply

mspr1nt November 9, 2010 at 11:54 am

If you really want to read what is said said to them you can simply type @ and their user name in the search bar and all the Tweets sent to them will come up :)
With regards to your other point, yep, Smith is damn ballsy and super aggressive which is just one of the things that has made him such a great captain. It should be a great series when India come here later the year, especially now that Twatajhan is an allrounder ;)

Reply

Aditi Verma March 13, 2011 at 11:41 pm

Here’s the thing- I’m Indian, but ever since I was a small child who used to stare at the TV screen trying to understand what the hell is going on I have always been mesmerised by South African cricket. Just beautiful. When the match fixing incident came to light I was too young to really understand what was going on, but the best thing to come out of it (for me) was Shaun Pollock’s captaincy. I loved him! Which is why the knee- jerk reaction of appointing Smith evoked an idiotically knee- jerk reaction of intense dislike at first sight from me for him.

It was only late last year (well after Polly’s retired) that I realised he didn’t ask for the captaincy, and that it must have been very, very hard on him- really quite unfair now that I think on it. I cannot comment much on his captaincy or batting because I used to avoid him as much as possible, but he does seem a lot more relaxed now. I think it would take someone special to not get completely crushed by all the opinions and expectations on such young shoulders- I just turned 22 and I wouldn’t be able to do anything of the sort, I am pretty sure. Also, the rest of the team seems pretty close too (on field and online). I don’t know whether this is a reaction to the ‘clique’ comment in Gibbs’ book (that the rest of the team wishes to back the captain, etc.) or just something natural in the team, but they seem to be friends playing for each other and their country.

Loved the match last night, and wouldn’t be too disappointed if they won the Cup. Maybe an India- SA final. :)

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: